Level Design Contest #34 - Playing Phase (Discussion Topic)

Started by IchoTolot, November 15, 2026, 02:52:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Guigui and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

Guigui

That was precise indeed. I thought I had those possibilies with the bomber up there blocked because too many lems would fall during the platformer, but you manage to isolate one worker beautifully !

Intended is not that precise, but the aim of the level is that it is hard to spot.

V4 uploaded.
My NeoLemmix level packs :

Save One: do you have what it takes to save one Lemming ?
16 Medium-Hard levels

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive. Present and Sunsoft ranks reversed.
Collaboration pack with JawaJuice. 60 Hard levels.

Bravo jolie Ln, tu as trouvé : l'armée de l'air c'est là où on peut te tenir par la main.

JawaJuice

@Guigui Finally have a solution for R2 V3. My method of 'eating the cake' may differ from yours, but hopefully you will allow it because I don't think I can take any more of this level haha XD I'm pretty sure the key aspects of my solution will be intended now!

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Hard levels.

Guigui

Congrats on solving my R2 level JawaJuice !

Your eating method is crazier than mine. At the very end I was wondering where those ding sounds were coming from : the non climber eating his very small pieces of the cake !! Very funny and clever. Definitely acceptable though, just harder to execute than how I do it.

The climbers routing at the end part is backroutish though, and defeats a trick I'd like to see here. Not very far but I'll still call it a backroute and work on an easy fix. Sorry if you have to eat the cake again if you want to solve again, but hey, this is Lem's 35-th  B-Day !
My NeoLemmix level packs :

Save One: do you have what it takes to save one Lemming ?
16 Medium-Hard levels

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive. Present and Sunsoft ranks reversed.
Collaboration pack with JawaJuice. 60 Hard levels.

Bravo jolie Ln, tu as trouvé : l'armée de l'air c'est là où on peut te tenir par la main.

JawaJuice

Quote from: Guigui on November 20, 2026, 06:35:06 PMCongrats on solving my R2 level JawaJuice !

Your eating method is crazier than mine. At the very end I was wondering where those ding sounds were coming from : the non climber eating his very small pieces of the cake !! Very funny and clever. Definitely acceptable though, just harder to execute than how I do it.

The climbers routing at the end part is backroutish though, and defeats a trick I'd like to see here. Not very far but I'll still call it a backroute and work on an easy fix. Sorry if you have to eat the cake again if you want to solve again, but hey, this is Lem's 35-th  B-Day !

Spoiler
Yeah, I thought about that and I believe what you actually want is no increase in RR at the beginning, then for one of the lemmings to start digging near the top of the far candle, and for the turned around lemming to build the platform and then build a bridge which he terminates by digging leaving an unclimbable surface. My method of eating the cake looks a bit mad, but it is thought out - by leaving that one strip, as long as you start the final digger at the right time, you will be able to time it (albeit with delay tactics) so that the non-climber gets there at the right time. I'm sure I could replicate that. You mentioned via PM something about cancelling a digger with a digger to leave a climbable gap but I didn't quite get that because the guy carries on digging when he's cancelled the other one, which still leaves a too-tall bit of terrain. Unless you mean you do that several times at the end of the cake, but that would be very hard to execute. TBH, I'm not totally in love with this level - it's a bit too execution-heavy vs puzzle-solving for my taste, but I know there's a place for both in the Lemmings world and some people favour the latter. It's personal preference really.

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Hard levels.

JawaJuice

@Guigui I have a solution for R1 V4. It looks better to me, just one element that feels backroutey but I can't see how else to turn the guy around! And he needs turning around because if he ascends either staircase, that's basically game over - there's no way back down. :shrug:

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Hard levels.

Guigui

Quote from: JawaJuice on November 20, 2026, 07:15:43 PM@Guigui I have a solution for R1 V4. It looks better to me, just one element that feels backroutey but I can't see how else to turn the guy around! And he needs turning around because if he ascends either staircase, that's basically game over - there's no way back down. :shrug:

You're actually quite close to intended, most solutions should indeed fail by a turn or two from this climber. The whole issue is to control him.

But now this turn you make is crazy ! I was sure that a walker could not be turned with a platformer this way, but now I may understand things a little better...

Trying some ASCII art now to explain what I understood, maybe NL experts here can confirm ?
F means feet of the lem (the actual dot you see in CPM), X means floor,  0 means void.

In the following situation, lemming can not start platforming because too far from the ledge :
000000000000
FXXXXXX00000

In the following situation, lemming can start platforming, this is what we do most of the time
000000000000
XXXXFXX00000

In the following situation, lemming can start platforming and the terrain will turn him immediatly ; this is what JawaJuice did to turn the lem in his last replay :
000000XXXXXX
XXFXXXX00000



My NeoLemmix level packs :

Save One: do you have what it takes to save one Lemming ?
16 Medium-Hard levels

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive. Present and Sunsoft ranks reversed.
Collaboration pack with JawaJuice. 60 Hard levels.

Bravo jolie Ln, tu as trouvé : l'armée de l'air c'est là où on peut te tenir par la main.

JawaJuice

@Guigui Solution for R1 V5. I reckon this should be intended, because it still works on a really old version of this level.

Spoiler
If I'm right, this is kind of a variation on Sunsoft 15 from our RLMegadrive pack :)


Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Hard levels.

Guigui

Yep, definitely intended. Congratulations on finally finding it  :thumbsup:
My NeoLemmix level packs :

Save One: do you have what it takes to save one Lemming ?
16 Medium-Hard levels

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive. Present and Sunsoft ranks reversed.
Collaboration pack with JawaJuice. 60 Hard levels.

Bravo jolie Ln, tu as trouvé : l'armée de l'air c'est là où on peut te tenir par la main.

JawaJuice

Quote from: Guigui on November 21, 2026, 11:17:35 PMYep, definitely intended. Congratulations on finally finding it  :thumbsup:

Ha, thanks dude, took me long enough! Very clever level - so hard to spot the solution.




Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Hard levels.

kaywhyn

Well thanks to your guys' post, I've updated the pack with Guigui's new R1 version. Icho and I would had missed it otherwise!

@Guigui

That's why the update topic says to remove and make a new post anytime you need to post an update to your levels. Your post is from yesterday and then you modified the post to add your R1 to it. Remember, post edits don't get reflected on the Lemmings Forums home page, which makes it easy to miss a level update this way. It's fine, got it this time. Just remember this for future reference ;)

JawaJuice

Yeah, I actually missed it too tbh - I was just randomly checking the Update topic and noticed a new version had been posted.

@Guigui New solution for R2 V4 :thumbsup: Hopefully it's closer to what you had in mind now. :) I didn't fiddle with the RR this time, though I still insist on 'eating the cake' my own way :D

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Hard levels.

Nessy

Excited to participate in another contest after so long! :thumbsup: Some really tough but very high-quality levels here. So far, I have only managed to complete 6 levels in Rule 1. Replays attached.

A Trapless Hell
Nice easy level. It was honestly a great breather after some of the other tough ones on this list.

A Traves de los Terrenos del Arbitro
Cool level! It took me a moment to realize what I had to do, and it was pretty tricky to lock in and get every Lemming where they had to be. Afterwards, it was very satisfying to see the final basher clones move through the entire level.

It's Not Unusual To Love Lemmings!
Nice simple level. I liked it! It was also another nice breather compared to some of the other levels on this list.

Mr Auto
I'm pretty sure my solution is intended or close to intended. Wow, this was a fantastic level! This one took me a few days to piece together. The biggest obstacle in the end was getting that climber to turn around multiple times, and once I figured it out, I was like, "Oh! That's why the entrance points to the left!" :D

Think Thrice!
Hopefully my solution is intended. This was another great level! I always love a one-of-everything level, and this one was very satisfying to solve. I especially love the use of the blocker to hold a Lemming in place while allowing a jumper to bounce off of them :thumbsup: The shimmier on the platformer was also a neat little trick.

Until The Wheels Fall Off (remix)
I think my solution is intended. A great level! It's funny how I was able to figure out most of the level, but bumping the release rate to 99 was the one piece of the puzzle I kept overlooking. It definitely helped me safely platform to the top floor with a more condensed crowd.
My Lemmings Packs:
- Lemmings Migration [NeoLemmix] - 40 levels
- Lemmings Migration [RetroLemmini] - Thanks ericderkovits for the conversion!
- Lemmings Destination [NeoLemmix] - 100 levels + 11 contest levels

Lemmings Projects In Development:
- Nothing yet

Guigui

It is nice to have you participate in the contest Nessy (and with a new Bloodborne avatar  :thumbsup: ), we did not have much opportunity to be on the forum at the same time yet, but I enjoyed your packs a lot when I played them.

Thank you for the kind words on my MrAuto level. Your solution is indeed intended, good job on finding it. It took me and playtesters (mainly JawaJuice) a lot of time to get there but I think it is kind of solid now ... well ... until kaywhyn tries it of course ;)
My NeoLemmix level packs :

Save One: do you have what it takes to save one Lemming ?
16 Medium-Hard levels

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive. Present and Sunsoft ranks reversed.
Collaboration pack with JawaJuice. 60 Hard levels.

Bravo jolie Ln, tu as trouvé : l'armée de l'air c'est là où on peut te tenir par la main.

kaywhyn

@Nessy

Thanks for playing my R1! :thumbsup: Your solution is pretty much intended/acceptable and interestingly enough is the exact same as both JawaJuice's and Crane's. Well done and thanks for the compliment! :thumbsup:

Spoiler
I bash to reach the exit instead and for the slider, I mine with him until he gets low enough and then I fence. Needless to say, you swapped the basher and fencer with one another, but it's fine ;)

Also you might have noticed I used the L3D Circus track here which you also used in your Lemmings Destination pack! This is honestly pretty much my top favorite track from L3D! :thumbsup:

Quote from: JawaJuice on November 20, 2026, 01:49:29 AMAwesome! Yes, it's another great level, @kaywhyn. I think this and your R3 in particular are among my favourites that I've played in the contest.

Thanks for the compliments! :thumbsup:


QuoteIt was worth the effort in patching all of the backroutes for R1 as it's really solid now. You're quite right, it would look better on the replay if I assigned permanent skills earlier. Of course I know I can do that and I can't really explain why I don't sometimes - just a bad habit of mine that pausing and frame-stepping allows me to do quite easily I guess.

No worries at all. I just had to say it because I happened to notice it while watching your replay :laugh:

Quote
Spoiler
The reason that the blocker/jumper part of the solution is hard to spot is probably just that it's not a commonly used interaction - the same way way blocker/shimmier isn't either, but can sometimes be useful depending on the level.

The first interaction mentioned was definitely the hardest to enforce in my level, and while I was designing it I realized it may be quite hard to in general. At least from my thoughts and observations, it seems to require extremely specific setups, since most of the time

Spoiler
you can simply let the Lemming turn on the blocker first and then assign the jumper. However, as you have seen in my level, all the blocker does is to simply hold the Lemming in place rather than its standard function of turning other Lemmings around ;) Coincidentally, the blocker serves the same function on my R3! :laugh: I think I can definitely see why you like both my R1 and R3 a lot. For the latter, I was trying to go for a "The Great Lemming Caper" vibe. I remember there was a custom level I played that did something similar, though I can't remember who it was by or from what pack it comes from, and that really bugs me, as I've pretty much combed through all my playlists on my channel and I can't seem to find it :( 

@Guigui

Again, please remember to remove your post in the update topic and make a new post anytime you release an update for your levels. In the future, if you want me or Icho to include your updated level(s) in the pack, please abide by the rules of that topic as outlined in Icho's post. Once you remove and create a new post attaching your updated level(s), we'll be happy to update the pack with it/them included ;)

Quote from: Guigui on Today at 12:58:46 PMThank you for the kind words on my MrAuto level. Your solution is indeed intended, good job on finding it. It took me and playtesters (mainly JawaJuice) a lot of time to get there but I think it is kind of solid now ... well ... until kaywhyn tries it of course ;)

:laugh: :thumbsup: