Level Design Contest #34 - Playing Phase (Discussion Topic)

Started by IchoTolot, November 15, 2026, 02:52:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

IchoTolot (+ 1 Hidden) and 6 Guests are viewing this topic.

Kingshadow


Crane

Quote from: JawaJuice on November 16, 2026, 10:55:39 PMMy backroutes solutions for all the R2 levels except Kingshadow's. Best I can do on that one is 33/34 - such an annoying level!
As you probably guessed... a horrible backroute!

Crane

Got "Eyes On The Target!" solved.  If you aren't a master of Sliders (which I'm not!), you're not going to solve this one - damn that level was deliciously devious!

IchoTolot

Here is the new feedback to the solutions to my levels:

@Crane Intended soltion to my R1!

QuoteIf you aren't a master of Sliders (which I'm not!), you're not going to solve this on

So either you are indeed a master of Sliders, or you do not need to be one to solve it.  :8():
Anyway, well done on your solution!  :thumbsup:

@JawaJuice Your solution to my R2 is also intended.  :)

@Kingshadow And your solutions to R1 and R3 also also intended.  :)


I don't know if I am able to update the pack today as I am busy (so keep an eye on the update topic), but I lukily got another helping hand in kaywhyn.  ;)

kaywhyn

Quote from: IchoTolot on Today at 07:24:07 AMI don't know if I am able to update the pack today as I am busy (so keep an eye on the update topic), but I lukily got another helping hand in kaywhyn.  ;)

Yup, got you covered ;) Pack is currently up-to-date with the latest versions of every level that has had an update posted :) In general, I tend to update the pack very frequently as authors post updates for their levels. Only thing that's still missing is Guigui's R1 music track, but it's not super crucial in any way, as that is for the music pack, not the contest level pack. The pack itself and his R1 level is still playable without his intended music track. It simply means other players who have not downloaded the music pack for Strato's Lemmings World Tour level pack will just have a track from the standard rotation playing on Guigui's R1 instead. 

Kingshadow


JawaJuice

Rule 3 solutions attached, with the exception of JRT's. I ran into the problem described by others in the separate topic there, with the program throwing an exception and crashing when switching to Clear Physics Mode. And you can't not switch to CPM when you have this many teleporters to keep track of. @JRT, I don't want to be too harsh, but it almost seems like you designed this level to break NeoLemmix - I'm sure you didn't, but that is the net effect. To be honest, even if the crash is fixed (by reducing the amount of teleporters), I won't be playing this level as it stands. Keeping track of say, half a dozen teleporter pairs is already enough of a head fry, so 27+? No thanks. Besides which, the size of the map and the amount of objects on display brings my laptop to a crawl (and I don't have an under-powered machine in terms of VRAM, GPU etc), so it's an incredibly laggy, jittery experience that's just not fun to play. I would suggest either radically re-working the level or removing it from the contest, but that's your call obviously.

With all that said, there were some fine levels here, as there have been throughout each Rule - a very high level of design all around, which makes for an interesting contest! I'll turn my attention to trying to solve (and hopefully not re-backroute, though no promises!) the updated levels so far. :thumbsup:

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Medium-Hard levels.

Crane

Your solution is a backroute unfortunately.  Patching!

JawaJuice

@Crane, I do have a solution for your updated R1 but you're not going to like it. I really did try not to use no-one's favourite trick, but found I kept coming up a lemming short due to having to use all of the bombers and one blocker who couldn't be freed, so had to resort to it a couple of times. It's a lot less precise than my first solution though, FWIW. I'm sure there's a good reason you're providing 10 climbers (and not the spamming reason I used them for) but I don't know what it is.



Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Medium-Hard levels.

JawaJuice

@Guigui Updated R1. Sorry to drop another backroute on you dude but this level does seem quite prone to them unfortunately.

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Medium-Hard levels.

JRT

Quote from: JawaJuice on Today at 02:53:29 PMRule 3 solutions attached, with the exception of JRT's. I ran into the problem described by others in the separate topic there, with the program throwing an exception and crashing when switching to Clear Physics Mode. And you can't not switch to CPM when you have this many teleporters to keep track of. @JRT, I don't want to be too harsh, but it almost seems like you designed this level to break NeoLemmix - I'm sure you didn't, but that is the net effect. To be honest, even if the crash is fixed (by reducing the amount of teleporters), I won't be playing this level as it stands. Keeping track of say, half a dozen teleporter pairs is already enough of a head fry, so 27+? No thanks.


I know this level is an absolute monster and definitely isn't for everyone.

Just to clear up the Clear Physics Mode issue: you actually don't need to use CPM to keep track of the routing. I specifically built visual decorations directly into the level that explicitly show exactly where every single teleporter leads. The routing is entirely baked into the level design itself. Look for the roman numerals along the bottom of the level and corresponding tags elsewhere on steel plates near the other hatches. I specifically didn't want players to have the headache of hovering over teleports looking for individual pairs since its the bigger picture than matters.

I definitely didn't design this to break NeoLemmix! My goal was simply to push the engine's mechanical limits as far as they could possibly go to build a massive, interconnected puzzle. The CPM crash is just an unfortunate engine quirk when it tries to render the UI for that many pairs, and the lag is simply a byproduct of the extreme object density required to make a machine like this function.

I completely understand if keeping track of the routing is too much of a "head fry" and you decide to skip it. I won't be withdrawing it from the contest because it achieves exactly the mechanical concept I set out to build. All I ask other members of the community is to give it a chance, take a look at the level, its design, what the mechanics are and look at it from a holistic view instead of booting the level and clicking buttons.

I totally get that this kind of extreme, boundary-pushing level isn't going to be everyone's cup of tea.

kaywhyn

@Guigui

Got the music track for your R1 included in the music pack now. Thanks! :) I also removed your two earlier posts from the update topic so that it sticks to just one post per author. I've done it for you this time, but please remember to remove your older posts in the future and just have one post in that topic. You're fine, you're new to these contests ;)

Also, don't feel bad for all the level updates you've needed to submit due to backroutes. That's why we have pre-testers and the playing phase so that we can weed out any further backroutes that were missed! As another person has also stated earlier, some levels are just very prone to backroutes :( 

edit: I did indeed forget something, and that is I've added the music track for lemmkeev20's R2 to the music pack as well!

I also updated the pack, including adding lemmkeev20's R2 level to the pack, and hopefully got all level updates included! Let me know if I've missed any!

@lemmkeev20

Feel free to submit any of your future level submissions to the update topic if you wish to enter for R1 and R3 as well. Now that the playing phase has started, you don't need to ask if you can join. As such, I've removed that post where you asked that question from the topic, as there wasn't any level file attachment and therefore it doesn't belong in it ;)

@Kingshadow and @JawaJuice

Nice and different backroutes from the both of you for my R3! For V3, I shifted a trap over and removed a steel pipe. Also added a background, but that's just purely visual! Not sure how I forgot about that! :forehead: 

Kingshadow

Quote from: kaywhyn on Today at 06:54:24 PM@Kingshadow and @JawaJuice

Nice and different backroutes from the both of you for my R3! For V3, I shifted a trap over and removed a steel pipe. Also added a background, but that's just purely visual! Not sure how I forgot about that! :forehead: 

Resolved V3 of kaywhyn's Rule 3.

kaywhyn

@Kingshadow

That's intended for my R3 now! Well done! :thumbsup:

Kingshadow