ccexplore = ''Youtube is full of these kinds of music video combining music (often remixed/remastered) with random snippets of video, only some of which are related to the video game''.
It wasn't just Finlay saying the video was unrelated but you too ccexplore.
Yes, but it wasn't a criticism. I was just pointing out to Finlay that a lot of youtube videos of video game music tends to be like that, it isn't meant to be a judgment call. My only negative feedback was on the music itself, that as a remix it wasn't very distinguished (for example, seeing that it featured Sonic in the video, I was thinking it would've at least go into some sort of Medley or fusion of some Sonic music).
Anyway, I think you're blowing this way out of proportion.
Only Finlay and I has any kind of feedback that is "negative", Simon's feedback is basically positive, and no one else has any feedback (so neutral majority basically). And only Finlay objected to the "random" imagery. And of course no one bothered to research anything
because we didn't know it's not random! With youtube having so many videos of all kinds of quality and relevance, and having no prior knowledge, is it not reasonable to assume that the video features Sonic because whoever made the video also like Sonic games, and that maybe the girl is the same person who made the video? In which case there would be no reason for us to expect any further research, correct? Sorry you feel so negatively about the feedback, but it's hardly civil to call our feedback and opinions "bitching" either, you know.
===========
As for the video of the girl, I honestly can't say I particularly like my Lemmings music being turned into
that , but that's my personal taste (and there's no denying that it does make for a memorable video), and I certainly have no objections to posting it here.