Level Design Contest #34 - Playing Phase (Discussion Topic)

Started by IchoTolot, November 15, 2026, 02:52:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 8 Guests are viewing this topic.

kaywhyn

@JawaJuice

Ok, I had a feeling someone could possibly try that at the start for my R1 but I didn't do anything about it at the time to prevent it :forehead: For V9, added some more terrain.

JawaJuice

@lemmkeev20 Updated R2 solution. :thumbsup:

@Crane I believe this will now be your intended solution for R2. It's worth noting that it can be backrouted slightly using the dreaded basher-blocker turnaround trick, but I'll spare you the pain of having to see that replay ;) Really, any level that contains both bashers and blockers is going to run this risk and it's maybe not worth fixing unless it completely changes how a player completes the level - not sure how you feel about it? In this case, I would argue it doesn't fundamentally change the solution, just saves using a couple of skills.

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Medium-Hard levels.

JawaJuice

@kaywhyn Intended? :) I don't see anything that looks obviously backroutey about this solution.

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Medium-Hard levels.

Crane

Quote from: JawaJuice on November 19, 2026, 09:16:14 PM@lemmkeev20 Updated R2 solution. :thumbsup:

@Crane I believe this will now be your intended solution for R2. It's worth noting that it can be backrouted slightly using the dreaded basher-blocker turnaround trick, but I'll spare you the pain of having to see that replay ;) Really, any level that contains both bashers and blockers is going to run this risk and it's maybe not worth fixing unless it completely changes how a player completes the level - not sure how you feel about it? In this case, I would argue it doesn't fundamentally change the solution, just saves using a couple of skills.


Yep, that's intended, well done!  I can see where the Basher/Blocker interaction would go, and yes, it won't fundamentally change the solution - sure, it removes a trick, but since that interaction is so hard to reliably pull off, it's not worth patching, if it's even possible to do so.

kaywhyn

@JawaJuice

Finally! That is pretty much intended, but just like for my R2, you once again swapped the order of two of the skills ;) It's fine. The two main tricks I wanted to enforce in this level are both present in your solution, so it's very much in the spirit of the intended solution. Great job! :thumbsup:

Spoiler
In my solution, I bash at the end to reach the exit, while after mining with the slider to get low enough, I fence upwards to get back to the blocker to laser him free. Again, your solution swaps the basher and fencer, but it's fine, it's perfectly acceptable.

The two main tricks I wanted to enforce are the jumper/blocker and sliding and using the platformer to shimmy on back towards the starting area. Indeed, I'm a bit surprised that the jumper/blocker is the hardest part of the solution, though admittedly I don't think there's a custom level that yet relies on that interaction, so I thought I make a level enforcing such ;) 

Thanks again for playing and am glad you enjoyed the level! :thumbsup: Just one thing I've noticed from watching your replay, and that is you literally waited until the very last frame to assign both of the permanent skills. Remember, you can assign them way farther in advance and they will automatically carry out the appropriate action without you needing to do anything further :P Think for example my R3 where in your solution you assigned one of the permanent skills much farther in advance before the Lemming even needs to use the permanent skill! ;)   

Crane

I admit I read the spoiler, and when I did, the rest of the solution just presented itself!

kaywhyn

@Crane

Pretty much intended/acceptable. Interesting, it's pretty much the exact same solution as JawaJuice's. The fact that you both found the start of the level the hardest means I really underestimated my R1's difficulty! :lem-mindblown: Indeed, I did mention that while I intentionally made all my levels 1-of-everything this time, they still aren't trivial by any means! ;)

Anyway, this is wonderful feedback from the both of you that my R1 is the hardest this time out of my 3 levels. Thanks! :thumbsup: 

JawaJuice

Quote from: kaywhyn on November 19, 2026, 11:41:44 PM@JawaJuice

Finally! That is pretty much intended, but just like for my R2, you once again swapped the order of two of the skills ;) It's fine. The two main tricks I wanted to enforce in this level are both present in your solution, so it's very much in the spirit of the intended solution. Great job! :thumbsup:

Spoiler
In my solution, I bash at the end to reach the exit, while after mining with the slider to get low enough, I fence upwards to get back to the blocker to laser him free. Again, your solution swaps the basher and fencer, but it's fine, it's perfectly acceptable.

The two main tricks I wanted to enforce are the jumper/blocker and sliding and using the platformer to shimmy on back towards the starting area. Indeed, I'm a bit surprised that the jumper/blocker is the hardest part of the solution, though admittedly I don't think there's a custom level that yet relies on that interaction, so I thought I make a level enforcing such ;) 

Thanks again for playing and am glad you enjoyed the level! :thumbsup: Just one thing I've noticed from watching your replay, and that is you literally waited until the very last frame to assign both of the permanent skills. Remember, you can assign them way farther in advance and they will automatically carry out the appropriate action without you needing to do anything further :P Think for example my R3 where in your solution you assigned one of the permanent skills much farther in advance before the Lemming even needs to use the permanent skill! ;) 

Awesome! Yes, it's another great level, @kaywhyn. I think this and your R3 in particular are among my favourites that I've played in the contest. It was worth the effort in patching all of the backroutes for R1 as it's really solid now. You're quite right, it would look better on the replay if I assigned permanent skills earlier. Of course I know I can do that and I can't really explain why I don't sometimes - just a bad habit of mine that pausing and frame-stepping allows me to do quite easily I guess.

Spoiler
The reason that the blocker/jumper part of the solution is hard to spot is probably just that it's not a commonly used interaction - the same way way blocker/shimmier isn't either, but can sometimes be useful depending on the level.

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Medium-Hard levels.

JawaJuice

@GigaLem Another solution for your updated R2. Am I any closer to intended now?

Reverse Lemmings: Megadrive
Collaboration pack with Guigui. 60 Medium-Hard levels.

Crane

Quote from: JawaJuice on Today at 01:49:29 AM...the same way way blocker/shimmier isn't either, but can sometimes be useful depending on the level.

It's funny you should mention that.
Spoiler
I tried to employ that in my level "Containment" in Lemmings Cranium, but couldn't get it to reliably work for the level in question, so instead I used a shimmier/bomber interaction to control which way the shimmier falls upon hitting a wall.