Level Design Contest #34 - Playing Phase (Discussion Topic)

Started by IchoTolot, November 15, 2026, 02:52:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

IchoTolot

Also took a look at the level and I agree.

Did you maybe mean another ruleset?  ???

Otherwise as kaywhyn said, just because it took a while, doesn't mean it automatically gets in.

The rulesets can be ticky and that's why you are given over a month or even two to prepare!

lemmkeev20

Quote from: kaywhyn on Today at 07:41:45 PM@lemmkeev20

I've removed your attachments in the update topic. I don't think you even read the LDC #23 rulesets at all, as your R3 doesn't seem to satisfy any of them. As such, the level wouldn't be eligible. However, if you modify it so that it does satisfy them, Icho or I will add it to the pack.

Also removed your older post from the update topic. Please remember to do that in the future and stick to one post per user in that topic. I've already had to do this a few times for you, cleaning and tidying up the posts there after you.

Quote from: lemmkeev20 from LDC #34 update topic on Today at 02:52:47 PM(this took a long while so please add it to the contest)

Please be respectful: Icho or I are not going to add your level just because you claim it took a while to make. As mentioned above, the level doesn't even seem to satisfy any of the 3 rulesets of LDC #23. Please read them carefully again and modify the level as needed so that it does. When you make the necessary adjustments and re-attach your level in the update topic, then we can add it to the pack, but for now it's ineligible.

i mean to be honest the 3rd rule was confusing anyways but thanks :thumbsup:

anyways see ya next contest!

IchoTolot

Quote from: lemmkeev20 on Today at 08:39:55 PMi mean to be honest the 3rd rule was confusing anyways but thanks :thumbsup:

anyways see ya next contest!

Your new submission still does not statisfy the rule 3!

Read again!:


Pick one of the previous contests with 3 rules and make a level that satisfies all 3 of them.

Contest 23 had a rule that reads:

QuoteDivide your level into two sections.

    - Sizes and shapes of the sections are up to you.

You can choose two different tilesets, no more, no less. For the two tilesets you chose, use a different tileset in each section.

    - VGASPECs are not allowed.
    - You have to use the terrain pieces and objects from the same tileset in each section.

All hatch(es) need to be in one section, while all exit(s) need to be in the other section.

I don't want to be too strict here. If you use two different styles and they don't blend into one another, it's fine.

You new level did not statisfy that one for example.
In order to have an eligible level for rule 3 you need to satisfy all 3 rules of a previous contest!


lemmkeev20

Quote from: IchoTolot on Today at 09:13:13 PM
Read again!:


Pick one of the previous contests with 3 rules and make a level that satisfies all 3 of them.

Contest 23 had a rule that reads:

QuoteDivide your level into two sections.

    - Sizes and shapes of the sections are up to you.

You can choose two different tilesets, no more, no less. For the two tilesets you chose, use a different tileset in each section.

    - VGASPECs are not allowed.
    - You have to use the terrain pieces and objects from the same tileset in each section.

All hatch(es) need to be in one section, while all exit(s) need to be in the other section.

I don't want to be too strict here. If you use two different styles and they don't blend into one another, it's fine.

You new level did not statisfy that one for example.
In order to have an eligible level for rule 3 you need to satisfy all 3 rules of a previous contest!



jesus christ... :forehead:

i want to say a few things here

1: I didn't knew what was the y and x things for, the starting points?

2: I don't know to much what is VGASPECs

3: I used 2 different styles (orig_pillar and l2_classic)

4: i made 2 sections for each style

5: the first rule read as

QuoteMake a X of every Y different kind of skill level where X≤10 and Y≥5

    - Pick-up skills(if they exist) count towards the skill limit.
    - Pre-assigned skills on hatches or lemmings(if they exist) don't count towards the Y skill types limit.

and the second rule read as

QuoteMake a very small level with few lemmings and a tight timer.

    - The level must not be larger than 240x120 pixels. (3/4 of the default horizontal and vertical size, respectively)
    - The level gives at most a total of 10 lemmings. Neutals, pre-placed lemmings and cloners count towards the limit!
    - The level should have a time limit of 1 minute or less.

thats why i couldn't make the level any size

6: does it has to look something like this:?



and those are a few things that I wanted to note here (sorry if it sounded angry)

IchoTolot

Quote3: I used 2 different styles (orig_pillar and l2_classic)

4: i made 2 sections for each style

So you took 2 styles which are nearly identical (partly even are identical) and try to loophole it.

Normally I do not like being overly precise, but here I veto this.

I hereby state a general rule namida gave back in the day:

Quoteg. If your level is acceptable according to the letter of the contest's criteria, the host may still reject it if they feel it goes against the spirit of the criteria; or in other words, don't use loopholes in the contest's criteria.

The rule aims to create different looking level sections and this I rate as a loophole against the the spirit of the criteria.

It also reads:

QuoteIf you use two different styles and they don't blend into one another, it's fine.

Your styles are different by name, but do blend into one another as they are nearly identical!

Please, don't try to game the rule and simply use two styles that are clearly distinct from one another and we can check it by simply looking at the level and not check every piece individually!

There are so many styles to choose from, why try to strech it?

Rule 1 from that contest simply states in mathematical terms:

Make a level with at least 5 different skill types (skill types = Y). That all have the same use count and at most 10 uses each - pick up skills count toward this limit (use count = X).
Pre-assigned skills on hatches or lemmings(if they exist) don't count towards the skill type limit.


If you have questions: Ask first and only then create and submit a level!

kaywhyn

Quote from: lemmkeev20 on Today at 08:39:55 PMi mean to be honest the 3rd rule was confusing anyways but thanks :thumbsup:

anyways see ya next contest!

Quote from: lemmkeev20 on Today at 09:29:48 PM
Quote from: IchoTolot on Today at 09:13:13 PM
Read again!:


Pick one of the previous contests with 3 rules and make a level that satisfies all 3 of them.

Contest 23 had a rule that reads:

QuoteDivide your level into two sections.

    - Sizes and shapes of the sections are up to you.

You can choose two different tilesets, no more, no less. For the two tilesets you chose, use a different tileset in each section.

    - VGASPECs are not allowed.
    - You have to use the terrain pieces and objects from the same tileset in each section.

All hatch(es) need to be in one section, while all exit(s) need to be in the other section.

I don't want to be too strict here. If you use two different styles and they don't blend into one another, it's fine.

You new level did not statisfy that one for example.
In order to have an eligible level for rule 3 you need to satisfy all 3 rules of a previous contest!



jesus christ... :forehead:

i want to say a few things here

1: I didn't knew what was the y and x things for, the starting points?

2: I don't know to much what is VGASPECs

3: I used 2 different styles (orig_pillar and l2_classic)

4: i made 2 sections for each style

5: the first rule read as

QuoteMake a X of every Y different kind of skill level where X≤10 and Y≥5

    - Pick-up skills(if they exist) count towards the skill limit.
    - Pre-assigned skills on hatches or lemmings(if they exist) don't count towards the Y skill types limit.

and the second rule read as

QuoteMake a very small level with few lemmings and a tight timer.

    - The level must not be larger than 240x120 pixels. (3/4 of the default horizontal and vertical size, respectively)
    - The level gives at most a total of 10 lemmings. Neutals, pre-placed lemmings and cloners count towards the limit!
    - The level should have a time limit of 1 minute or less.

thats why i couldn't make the level any size

6: does it has to look something like this:?



and those are a few things that I wanted to note here (sorry if it sounded angry)

That's why Icho allows a long period for the submission phase! Take a look at the Level Design Contest #34 Thread for example. Notice how some users posted and asked questions there because they weren't sure about some things about the rulesets. You could had done the same thing and asked questions in case there was any confusion and if you had any to get clarifications from either Icho or me ;)

Quote from: IchoTolot on Today at 10:03:13 PM
Quote3: I used 2 different styles (orig_pillar and l2_classic)

4: i made 2 sections for each style

So you took 2 styles which are nearly identical (partly even are identical) and try to loophole it.

Normally I do not like being overly precise, but here I veto this.

Also agree there

lemmkeev20

welp, thanks :thumbsup: ,

now i understand better  ;)

but i guess thats the only rule i am not submitting a level :'( (for now) beacuse im still gonna be searching and if i have a question, ill ask it to you guys  ;)