I played the first three ranks in version 1.2. Replays are attached.

First a general comment: I noticed lots of level with time limits that are way above the actual time needed to complete the level. If they are not actually needed to prevent backroutes, I would prefer to have infinite time on such levels.

Warning: Spoilers ahead!

Tame (click to show/hide)

Tame 2 and Tame 8 should switch places.
Tame 3 is much harder than all other tame levels and should be moved to Crazy.
Tame 2 and Tame 10 were my favorites of this rank.

Crazy (click to show/hide)

Crazy 1: Much harder than the following levels. This is a typical bulletride level: A plethora of possible approaches, but hardly any work. Unfortunately this means that some failing attempts had neater ideas than the actual solution.
Crazy 2: Rather easy level, that could be moved to Tame.
Crazy 3: Given the terrain, I had hoped for a solution that doesn't purely go along the bottom.
Crazy 4: I save 10/10 in a probably not 100% intended way.
Crazy 5: I have one backroute and one other solution that seems more intended, but has lots of spare skills.
Crazy 6: Nice and relatively easy level. Could be moved earlier.
Crazy 7: Lots of fiddling around.
Crazy 8: I really don't see a different approach, but my solution doesn't feel completely intended. Especially the miner usage feels weird.
Crazy 9: Amazing level (now that the backroutes are removed), but could well be in the next rank.
Crazy 10: I can save 39 lemmings, so I suspect a backroute.

Wild (click to show/hide)

Wild 1: Very clever level.
Wild 2: Theme "Look around until you find a place where one can do with one skill less".
Wild 3: Very nice level.
Wild 4: Could be moved to Crazy. After one counts the builders, the path is obvious.
Wild 5: I probably said so already in your weekly pack thread, but this is similar to Tame 2: Fiddle around with the destructive skills until all lemmings are caught.
Wild 6: Nice level, but a bit hard on the timing.
Wild 7: Likely a slight backroute, as I save all lemmings and don't use all climbers and floaters.
Wild 8: Another typical bulletride level (cf Crazy 1). Again the actual solution feels less elegant than some other approaches.
Wild 9: Somehow I don't need the second miner. The beginning needs a lot of fiddling around until no lemming falls down into the gap on the left.
Wild 10: And another typical bulletride level (cf Crazy 1). And again the solution is a bit of a disppointment after lots of more ingenious attempts.

Rsolved the 2 Havoc levels

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

1 seems ~ intended, but 2 I think is an even bigger backroute now

Also could you reset the level id of Havoc 5 to a new one? (There is a button for that in the editor) The Mass Replay checker matches it with the Wild version and gives out that the replay has failed. I suspect you simply altered the level and saved it under a different name ---> keeping the same id.

I even should have pointed out earlier that I played the levels on the exp version

Quote from: namida on March 08, 2017, 11:06:31 AM

NL does this automatically these days; it isn't something bulletride has done.

Yikes, that's obnoxious Can you add an override for packs that use only the classic 8 skills?

Getting back on-topic, I've played through Crazy, solved all but two. Feedback:

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

5: Unsolved. This is much too hard for Crazy, especially when the next level is nearly trivial.
7: Basher-digger staircase, one of my least favourite tricks due to the precision required. Still, it was a good puzzle working out how to save all three groups with only 3 builders.
8: Unsolved.
9: Replay attached in case it's a backroute, this was very simple.
10: Replay attached to show the route I took. Not happy about the fact that the worker lemming's second bridge goes over a thorn, making an unclimbable step and forcing me to redo the entire solution to bomb the thorn.

Just played through Tame. These are fun levels so far, and I'm looking forward to continuing with the pack. I only have a couple of criticisms so far. For one thing, the exit on Level 10 is missing its flag

This is mostly a personal peeve, but in levels that use the classic 8 skills and only one or two are missing, it annoys me when the skill is removed, as then it takes a moment or two to look at all the skills and work out which are missing, whereas if you leave a gap then I know instantly. I know namida has been pushing for removing the skills, so maybe it's worth having a general discussion somewhere.