Lemmings Forums

Lix => Lix Main => Topic started by: Dullstar on November 27, 2024, 08:55:39 PM

Title: [UX] Unclear meaning of ?! icon
Post by: Dullstar on November 27, 2024, 08:55:39 PM
Best Guess: probably means the level has been changed since it was last solved.

Expected behavior: This icon isn't something I expect to see, so I would expect some sort of obvious way to see more information about it, either by hovering over it (e.g. tooltips), by clicking on it, or by selecting the associated level. Icons are good shorthand but ultimately users aren't psychic, so if cause and effect isn't obvious some textual explanation may be warranted.
Title: Re: [UX] Unclear meaning of ?! icon
Post by: Forestidia86 on November 27, 2024, 09:06:55 PM
Quote from: Dullstar on November 27, 2024, 08:55:39 PMBest Guess: probably means the level has been changed since it was last solved.


That is what it means.

There is issue #310 (https://github.com/SimonN/LixD/issues/310) that covers this problem.
I agree that the symbol is unclear.
Title: Re: [UX] Unclear meaning of ?! icon
Post by: Simon on November 28, 2024, 10:42:13 AM
Right, ancient UI bug.

It's a good idea to explain it in words. E.g.: When you click a level, then, in the level stats beside lix saved, we print the icon again, along with explanation of the icon. For the regular checkmark, "Solved" is enough. For the outdated icon, I don't have a snappy suggestion. "Solved an earlier version"? "You've solved an earlier version of <level title>"?

Yeah, it's a bad icon. Better would be (checkmark, question mark), not (question mark, bang). But even that's not obvious. Hmm: Checkmark with cowebs. Checkmark with stopwatch. Checkmark with hourglass, although that means waiting/computing. Checkmark with mustache. <_<;

-- Simon
Title: Re: [UX] Unclear meaning of ?! icon
Post by: WillLem on November 28, 2024, 09:14:02 PM
+1 for ToolTips when hovering over a UI item. Lix already does this excellently in-game (and in the options menu!), perhaps a new UI panel can be devoted to this in the level select menus as well.