To be honest, I've never played Chronicles before, but I saw some videos and thought the gameplay looked pretty cool (with great visuals), so...
Lemmings: 5
ONML: 6
Chronicles: 2 (+1)
Paintball: 0 (-2)
Revolution: 3
Sorry, Paintball. Though I do like the music, and the gameplay is very different. I've played a demo of the game and found the levels to be quite tricky.