Here's the results so far:
joe01 - Level 1 - A fun startNumber of Lemmings: 50
To save: 25 (50%)
Release Rate: 10
Skills: No climbers or floaters, 20 of everything else.
Good: Simple level for its place in the pack. Nice design...
Okay: ...although a little sloppy. I hope "A fun start" refers to the difficulty level.
Plus, the part of the design that's there is decent looking, but for the rest,
another lack of decorative terrain. Why is this always lacking in levels, both custom and official?
Bad: Isn't very fun to play, not please with going back to grab stats. It appears there's a 100% solution, but if it works, it's hard to pull off due to the water trigger areas. Could have been avoided rather easily through better placement of terrain.
joe01 - Level 2 - The Crusher
Lemmings: 50
To save: 40 (80%)
Release Rate: 20
Skills: 10 builders
Good: The traps can be seen, so to anyone who has played Lemmings, it should be clear that it isn't just watch the lemmings enter the exit.
Okay: Again, rather plain-looking. Decorative terrain is generally a good thing.
Bad: Gotta love misbehaving trigger areas, you can never tell what the highest altitude they're willing to strike at. Although, this cannot be solved easily without severely changing the level. This makes clearing the level, well, a little annoying the first time. Solution is way too obvious, and the trapdoor sticking in the ceiling is ugly.
Note: Sometimes a level's solution should be obvious, but this doesn't feel like one of those cases to me. I can tell it's not backrouted, as well. Is a backroute even possible with this skill set?
joe01 - Level 3 - An unhealthy optionLemmings: 40
To save: 25 (62%)
Release Rate: 50
Skills: 20 builders, 10 bashers
Good: Definately a nice looking level from the veiwpoint the game provides.
Okay: The building isn't too bad, but it's slow.
Bad: At first, it looks intimidating, but then you see the skillset. Woah, that's easy!
joe01 - Level 4 - Another twist of lemming, pleaseLemmings: 50
To save: 50 (100%)
Release Rate: 50
Skills: 1 climber, 50 floaters, 4 builders, 1 basher, 1 digger
*white flags level*
VERY VERY VERY VERY VERY VERY VERY VERY BAD: Requires one to click on fifty lemmings, make a lemming dig really deep, taking at least a minute, and a basher must be told to go the right way in a really small space. GAAAAAAAAAH!